Religion, Crime, and Punishment

Assistant Teaching Professor Hunter Bragg explores the intersection of religious values and the criminal legal system, and UT students will join his research.
Assistant Teaching Professor Hunter Bragg is leading research on the connections between Christian concepts like “forgiveness” and alternative forms of accountability and repair in the criminal legal system.
Working with UT’s Appalachian Justice Research Center (AJRC), Bragg is measuring the experience of East Tennesseans who have been harmed by serious violence. Interviews and surveys of people who experienced assaults, robberies, and other crimes also will inquire about their needs for healing.
“I’ll be asking, for instance, whether a person who is recovering from a violent assault desires harsh punishment for the responsible party, assurances of future safety, an explanation and apology from the wrongdoer, some other form of restitution, or some combination of these,” Bragg explained. “I will ask, further, whether there are connections between the types of justice they desire and their religious values, commitments, and practices.”
He also is partnering with the Raphah Institute, a nonprofit organization based in Nashville that supports people harmed by serious violence and guides responsible parties through meaningful accountability and repair.
Students from across the university will work with Bragg and the institute through a course with the Appalachian Justice Research Lab, conducting, coding, and interpreting the research.
“My hope is that students interested in law, policy, and/or the role of religion in public life will be drawn to this course and will gain a sense of how they might be able to contribute to positive and meaningful change in the world,” the professor said.
Raphah Institute is working on policy proposals for the Tennessee legislature that would expand accountability and repair access throughout the state, so the work also will give students a front-row seat to policy work, Bragg said.
“The best kind of academic research and the best kind of teaching challenges our assumptions about the world—like, say, whether locking people up actually makes the rest of us safer. The value of this work is that we come to have respect for many different positions and that we learn to hold our positions with humility,” Bragg said. “I’m grateful to be in a position to help students engage in that work of self-reflection here at UT.”
As a graduate student, Bragg realized how religion is infused in American society, and a seminar on the death penalty convinced him that the practice has roots in religious ideas of punishment.
“A few years later, I read Michelle Alexander’s The New Jim Crow and realized that there was a theo-logic to the practice of incarceration in the US,” he said. “I wanted to explore how that logic works, both intellectually, in the kinds of reasons we give for why punishment is necessary, and materially, in the lives of those who are affected by that punishment.”
Currently Bragg also is working on a book that examines plea bargains as a confession ritual. “It uses ritual theory to consider how plea-bargaining transforms defendants into criminals and justifies their punishment at the hands of the state,” he said.